| User | Post |
|
9:50 am August 28, 2009
| sr103
| | |
| New Member | posts 1 |
|
|
So, I'm 22, a girl, born in india and raised in the US (since i was like 5). I'm the first person in my huge family to be raised in the US…so there's pressure. Actually, not so much pressure as complete confusion. Everything i've ever done from choosing not to be an engineer/doctor, to living by myself instead of with my parents till I get married, to managing my own finances, has been a battle. Small ones, but battles nonetheless. I feel like I have to teach my parents about everything, who are, needless to say, incredibly traditional. They don't understand dating, let alone dating a non-indian.
Enter Me: I've been dating a wonderful man for about 2 years now. He's 25, southern, baptist and pretty amazing. Religion is not an issue with us cause we both know we're from different backgrounds and oddly enough, I actually celebrate the fact that I'm Indian more when i'm with him. Either way, it's been 2 years and i'm in grad school now, and i'd like to get married sometime in the next couple of years.
My question is, how do I start the conversation with my family? I mean, I know I need to be calm, address their fears etc. But logistically, what do I do? Do I tell them now or should I wait till later? Not telling them is killing me…and I think it's mean to not give them any indication and one day show up with an engagement ring…but maybe that's the best way? They need time to get used to this, but I dont know how to tell them now. I have no idea what to do.
Anyone have personal stories to tell about this? How did you first approach the topic? How old were you? How sure were you of the person you were with? I specially wanna hear from Indian women who went against the grain.
Thanks!
|
|
|
8:20 pm September 11, 2009
| heather
| | |
| Member | posts 20 |
|
|
Well, I'm not Indian but my fiance is, so I can't offer you the best advice. I understand how you feel where you want to tell your family. It made me sooo sad that we had to be a secret so long. I was terrified I was going to be rejected and would lose the relationship I was so invested in and the man I loved. I love thatyou feel more yourself with him and more indian. that's great. To me, you've found THE ONE!
But i'm american and that idea is very american, to be with the one, to be happy. It sounds like you've made a lot of your own moves that are not typical for Indian women. I I would suggest you do what my own guy did, he slowly started talknig about me until one day, when he finally told them who I was, they already had figured it out a while ago and were just so overjoyed.
So I have a happy ending telling his parents, instantly happy, nothing bad… not even about being older, they wanted to respect me and not discuss it anymore than just trusting my fiance's decision to marry me. I know you might not have the same experience… it's going to just suck until you know. It sucks worrying about the wave about to hit you. It might just be simple. It might knock you down. I wish I knew. But I know that we have stopped all major fights since they knew. I lost my fear of rejection and insecurities.
oh good luck. i know how hard it is.
|
|
|
8:48 pm March 6, 2010
| matungawest
| | |
| Member | posts 8 |
|
|
I'm an Indian man and I was in your shoes 11 yrs ago. I totally went against the grain although what I did would shock even Americans.. and I wasn't even raised here in the USA.
I was a grad student when I met my first wife. I got married and even had a son and my parents (oh, my parents were in India) did not know about this for about 2 yrs. When they came to visit my sister in Canada, I took my new family with me to surprise them. Surprised they were.. big time. In the end though they are parents and if they love you they will forgive you. They were too preoccupied being fascinated by their cute grandson to be mad at me.
Sorry, I don't have any soft solutions for you. Sometimes the only way to deal with hard-headed parents is to bring home the point the hard way.
|
|
|
8:57 pm March 6, 2010
| matungawest
| | |
| Member | posts 8 |
|
|
I was in your shoes 11 yrs ago. I was 26 (born and raised in India) grad student in the USA and my parents were in India back then. I married my first wife and had my first son without even telling my parents or sister. I'm not proud of what I did. Under the circumstances, it felt like the right thing to do. At 26, I'm already away from my parents and my sister hacking it on my own and I felt that if my parents can trust me to do the right thing career & education wise, they can trust me to do the right thing in my personal life. My parents however are cool though. They have an excellent mix of Indian subjectivity and Western objectivity. My pulling that stunt, I'm sure took them by surprise but they were ok with it in the end.
Don't miss out on an opportunity of a lifetime (meeting the right person in your life) because of a reaction it will beget from the people you know. The former will outlive the latter. The people you know will eventually come to terms with whatever action you take. No real parents can hold a grudge towards their children for long.
I don't have a politically correct solution for your situation, but all I can say that if you trust your gut, you will be fine.
|
|
|
12:59 pm April 26, 2010
| Gori Lady
| | Canada | |
| Member | posts 3 |
|
|
sr103 said:
So, I'm 22, a girl, born in india and raised in the US (since i was like 5). I'm the first person in my huge family to be raised in the US…so there's pressure. Actually, not so much pressure as complete confusion. Everything i've ever done from choosing not to be an engineer/doctor, to living by myself instead of with my parents till I get married, to managing my own finances, has been a battle. Small ones, but battles nonetheless. I feel like I have to teach my parents about everything, who are, needless to say, incredibly traditional. They don't understand dating, let alone dating a non-indian.
Enter Me: I've been dating a wonderful man for about 2 years now. He's 25, southern, baptist and pretty amazing. Religion is not an issue with us cause we both know we're from different backgrounds and oddly enough, I actually celebrate the fact that I'm Indian more when i'm with him. Either way, it's been 2 years and i'm in grad school now, and i'd like to get married sometime in the next couple of years.
My question is, how do I start the conversation with my family? I mean, I know I need to be calm, address their fears etc. But logistically, what do I do? Do I tell them now or should I wait till later? Not telling them is killing me…and I think it's mean to not give them any indication and one day show up with an engagement ring…but maybe that's the best way? They need time to get used to this, but I dont know how to tell them now. I have no idea what to do.
Anyone have personal stories to tell about this? How did you first approach the topic? How old were you? How sure were you of the person you were with? I specially wanna hear from Indian women who went against the grain.
Thanks!
|
|
|
1:06 pm April 26, 2010
| Gori Lady
| | Canada | |
| Member | posts 3 |
|
|
okay so I messed up on how to reply… SORRY!
I completely understand your situation. Ummm I am wondering just HOW traditional they are and how hard of a fight it is when you tell them you like to do things differently…My boyfriends family wont accept that he has taken on some of our western ideals and they wont accept that he isnt the same as them. I am not sure I can tell you what to do but I can give you an example of what has happened with us. I asked my boyfriend to tell his parents about us early as I didnt think it was fair to them to just show up oneday as engaged and not have them know we were dating. I also didnt like the idea of him lying to them all the time to see me. What they care about most seems to be presitge and status for him (money!!) and arent' too concerned about him being in love…anyhow! It has been a real hell for us dealing with all the terrible things they say to him and do to him. I dont regret it because I want to have an honest and open relationship, however I know he feels sometimes he wishes they didnt know because it makes his life hell. It really depends on how serious you are about marriage I guess. I'd write down the ways you guys are compatible and how you plan to do things like not one way or the other but both ways like a merging of the cultures. Maybe explain to them about how you respect the values you've been taught but feel your heart is leading you in this path and how happy you are with him. Whatever you decide be prepared for anything and everything and be strong for him and you. They will have to accept it eventually when they see how serious you two are and how much you are in love.
|
|
|
1:20 pm July 24, 2010
| NS
| | United States | |
| Member | posts 3 |
|
|
I'm in the same boat with you. Well, I'm younger, and I'm not in the situation where I'm ready to be married. But I feel, my boyfriend and I would like to get married.
I go to school away from home, so we have a chance to be together, my boyfriend and I. During summer vacations, this proves to be a problem. But X (let's call my boyfriend X), seems to be fine with this as a temporary situation. Hopefully, I'll so move out of the house for grad school.
I'm not sure how I'd break it to my parents because not only would this be an inter-racial union, but an inter-religious one. I'm Muslim, he's Christian. I know, technically, in Islam a woman cannot marry outside the faith. But, being open with my interpretations and understandings, I believe the two of us can work together and create a home and family for ourselves. X, on the other hand, believes one of us will have to convert, and he doesn't want to be the one. I am willing to accept X with his faith as long as I am able to practice my religion without inhibition.
How do I deal with my parents (who are strict, traditional, Muslim, Bangladeshis) and the inter-faith issue at once? Is it too much to handle? Has anyone else been through a situation similar to this?
|
|
|
|