Gori Girl Forums

You must be logged in to post Login Register


Lost Your Password?

Search Forums:


 






Wildcard Usage:
*    matches any number of characters
%    matches exactly one character

Would his Indian parents ever accept a chinese daughter in law ?

UserPost

12:35 pm
December 5, 2009


Frutiixpebble

New Member

posts 1

I've just started dating a Indian guy that was born and raised in India but immigrated to the U.S. when he was in High School. He is the sweetest guy ever. When I met him, he was living with his father only until recently his mother and sister came from India ( it was not the first time his mother and sister came to the states). He told his family about me and they did not like it at all that their only and youngest son/brother is dating a chinese girl. He would tell me that his mother and sister would say negetive things about me, for example, don't trust chinese girls, etc. He tells me that he's going to marry me no matter what his family says, also he has been in alot of arguments with his family because of me. ( Also got kicked out of the house once because of me) I am really confuse on why they can't accept that their son is dating me and that he's happy, why can't they also be happy? Since his 2nd sister is getting marrried next week, he's been really busy but he manage to see me at least once a day and we talk on the phone only when he's not around his family. Sometimes I wonder, would I ever get to meet his family and if I do, would they treat me in a negetive way or accept the fact that their son/brother is happy dating me. I understand that his family is well respectable but come on, im not trying to be selfish, its just that its the year 2009, must they be so strict ?


4:32 pm
December 5, 2009


alexa

Chicago, IL

Member

posts 7

Not that this exactly helps or anything, but one of the running jokes in V's family and few Indian friends is "at least she isn't Chinese"… (I'm white) but of course I didn't think much of it until I read your post. I know that there has been a long history of conflict with China. Maybe this article helps? http://www.newsweek.com/id/217088

7:40 pm
December 5, 2009


UGA

Member

posts 3

Frutiixpebble,  You may want to search on IndiaMike forums and Facebook for Chinindian groups. There are lot of discussions and advise on Chinese-Indian relationship. You will find lot of successful Chinese-Indian marriages and Chinese-Indian couples living in US, UK, India, China, Australia and other countries. I know several Indian-Asian couples with one spouse either Chinese, Taiwanese, Japanese or Korean. My wife is Japanese, most probably the reason I am more aware of other Indian-Asian couples.

In my opinion, Indian culture has lot more in common with Asian cultures. If you grew up in traditional Chinese family, you most probably have better chances of impressing his parents with your manners, humbleness, respect for elders and family orientation. I will suggest that you first meet his parents as his friend/neighbor/co-worker/acquaintance rather than his date/gf. Once his parents get to know you slowly, they will be impressed with your manners. Unlike western culture, chinese culture is not known for any baggage considered to be detrimental to marriage/family long term so any resistance (Asian look, China-India war) will be short lived once they get to know you.

1:51 am
December 6, 2009


luckyfatima

Dubai, UAE

Member

posts 61

Post edited 1:55 am – December 6, 2009 by luckyfatima


I think it is really complex, but…

I find in general that South Asians do have and express open prejudices against Chinese people. There are the typical crude stereotypes about their being shrewd in business, that they will eat anything, that they are unattractive (I have heard the pejorative term in Urdu/Hindi ”chapta” meaning flat, which describes a face, sort of like the English terms about eyes and so forth)…although the desis I know love Chinese straight black hair and Chinese color white skin. These are nothing but cheap stereotypes…yet they persist in the same way they do in North American culture…only in North America there was a political correctness movement that swept open expressions of these sentiments under the rug to some extent, although slurs and racist thinking against Chinese still very much exist in N. America. But desis are not generally polically correct. They also openly make prejudiced statements about other desis who are not members of their own particular ethnic communities..so it's not like they only pick on the Chinese. In my opinion it is the cheap stereotypes about Chinese people, as well as the perception that they are unattractive that work against you for simply being Chinese, not the Indo-Chinese war issue. Sadly, I think the disgusting American stereotype about “Chinese girls are good in bed” has made it to India through the spread of US media, so there is that Chinese girl vixen image there, too. (the domination of US popculture, rife with stereotypes about different ethnic groups, affects the way Indians in India, as well as people all over the world, think about black Americans, too…US racism is very dangerous)

Can an Indian family accept a Chinese bride? I know several mixed Chinese-female desi guy couples, it does happen despite the prejudices. Such couples are not uncommon in Singapore and Malaysia, for instance. In my experience, China born Chinese wouldn't be so happy about their girl marrying an Indian guy either…I think the stereotype thing is mutual, anyway. There are also a lot of 3rd and 4th gen Chinese origin Indians and Pakistanis…I have a friend who is Chinese-Pakistani and married into a Punjabi PK family. She lives in a joint family with her in-laws, and she is really happy. She is knock-out gorgeous, by the way, but I hear desi aunties say things about her like “she is pretty, for a Chinese.” I know that isn't fun to hear (or read), but I am just being honest about the issue. UGA has some good advice about meeting the family and comparisons between Indian and Chinese culture, although you mentioned you are American and perhaps you or your family aren't so culturally Chinese, at least you may “get” the family orientedness of Indians.

I would say just persist with your relationship, try your best to impress the potential ILs, but know what you are up against.

Mat pooch ke kya haal hai mera teray peechay

5:34 pm
December 30, 2009


Gori Girl

Admin

posts 118

frutiixpebble, I'm not sure how you found this site, but I have two older posts – Initial Family Resistance to your Intercultural Relationship and Indian Parental Problems: When Your Intercultural or Interracial Relationship Is Suddenly an Issue which have a lot of great comments from various people about how to deal with family dififculties. Really, I feel that most cases of families not accepting an intercultural/interracial relationship comes from the family, not the specific ethnicity of the guy or girl – i.e. if you were white, white stereotypes would be trotted out, if you were black, black stereotypes would be mentioned, etc etc.


About the Gori Girl forum

Most Users Ever Online: 38

Currently Online:
10 Guests

Currently Browsing this Topic:
1 Guest

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3
Forums: 13
Topics: 221
Posts: 1630

Membership:

There are 1622 Members
There have been 14 Guests

There are 2 Admins

Top Posters:

sjtp – 107
D – 94
Jenn23 – 93
DJain – 88
julia – 64
kck – 63

Recent New Members: karensmith, jijoobose, lohmodv, ammyrodrics, IndianTechie, davidmartin

Administrators: Gori Girl (118 Posts), Aditya (9 Posts)